Movement I · Week 5 · Thursday, February 11

The University Under Neoliberalism

In short Before we meet (the milestone due, the reading, what to write and bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan and the identity statement exchange), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).

Your first milestone is due, and Brown gives us a sharp way to ask why we are here at all. Write the identity statement for yourself first. We read them together in class.

Kirsti

Read
Brown, two essays from 2003 and 2011 (about 45 pages)
Bring
Your Scholarly Identity Statement and your marked copy of Brown
Due
Milestone 1, Scholarly Identity Statement, before class

Brown argues neoliberalism remakes the subject, the citizen, the student, and the scholar. This week reads her account of the university alongside your first milestone, a statement of who you are as a scholar.

Before we meet

Milestone due: Scholarly Identity Statement

About 500 words. Who are you as a scholar? What do you care about, what animates your research, and why does it matter? Where did your questions come from, and what do you want your work to do in the world? Write from conviction, for a reader who wants to know what you care about. A summary of your CV or a list of topics does not meet the threshold. 20% of the final grade. Submit through Canvas, by email, or in hard copy.

Full guide to the Scholarly Identity Statement milestone

Read

Read with a pen. The marginalia guide describes the practice.

Write and bring

Questions to carry into the reading

ShowHide Questions to carry into the reading
  • Brown argues neoliberalism remakes identity, values, and ways of relating to the world. Do you recognize the remaking in yourself?
  • What does it mean to pursue a PhD in the humanities under neoliberalism? What are you investing in, and what return do others expect?
  • Brown argues neoliberal rationality recasts the citizen as an economic actor. Which are you being trained to be? Which do you want to be?
  • What is the university for? Has Brown changed your answer?
  • If the PhD is part self-investment and part critical refusal, how do you hold both at once?

When we meet

Session plan

ShowHide Session plan
TimeActivity
10:15–10:35Opening question: what is the university for? We answer before reading Brown back to ourselves.
10:35–11:10Brown’s 2003 essay: neoliberalism as political rationality, and the citizen and the economic subject.
11:10–11:35Brown’s 2011 essay: the public university and educated democracy.
11:35–11:50Break
11:50–12:35Identity statement exchange.
12:35–1:00Closing Movement I: what vocabulary do we now share?

Identity statement exchange

ShowHide Identity statement exchange

A close reading of each other’s statements, looking for conviction.

  1. Exchange statements with a partner you have not yet worked with closely.
  2. Read for ten minutes. Underline the most alive sentence. Circle anything written for a committee instead of from conviction. Write one question the statement opens for you.
  3. Share responses, five minutes of conversation per statement.
  4. As a group, name what keeps appearing across the statements, what we seem least sure of, and what we seem most sure of.

Written route. If you would rather respond in writing than in conversation, write your response on the back of your partner’s statement and hand it over in place of the five minutes of talk.

After we meet

Further reading, if this week opened something up

ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
  • Martha Nussbaum, Not For Profit: Why Democracy Needs the Humanities, the affirmative case for humanistic education.
  • Kathleen Fitzpatrick, Generous Thinking, on the public role of the university.
  • David Harvey, A Brief History of Neoliberalism, a companion to Brown.