Milestone 1 · Due before class, Week 5 (February 11) · 20% of the final grade
Scholarly Identity Statement
In short This page covers why you write it, the prompt, how to write it, step by step, what the statement is, and what it is not, check your draft, how it is assessed, submitting, generative AI, and getting help.
You write about 500 words, in your own voice, on who you are as a scholar: the questions which drive you, where they came from, and why they matter. You hand it in before class in Week 5, and we read the statements together in class.
- What you hand in
- One statement of about 500 words, in prose
- Due
- Before class, Thursday, February 11 (Week 5)
- Weight
- 20% of the final grade
- Submit
- Canvas, email, or a print copy in class
- What happens next
- You trade statements with a partner in class, and the statement feeds your prospectus in Movement III
Why you write it
Every later milestone asks you to choose: which faculty to ask, which texts to read, which problem to pursue. Those choices come easier once you have said, plainly, what you care about and why. The statement gives you this account early, while it still shapes the decisions. You will return to it when you write the rationale for your exam list and the stakes section of your prospectus.
The prompt
Who are you as a scholar? What do you care about, what animates your research, and why does it matter? Where did your intellectual questions come from, and what do you want your work to do in the world?
How to write it, step by step
- Week 3 or 4: freewrite for twenty minutes. Answer the prompt without stopping to edit. Use the entry points below if you stall.
- Find your sentence. Read the freewrite and underline the one sentence closest to what you believe. Build the statement around it.
- Draft in four moves. Name the questions you pursue. Say where they came from, in your reading, your work, or your life. Say why they matter, inside your field and beyond it. Name the people your work speaks with and speaks to.
- Read it aloud. Cut any sentence a stranger in your field would have written. Keep the ones only you would write.
- Check it against the table below, then submit before class on February 11.
Some ways in. Use the ones which help, and skip the rest.
- What brought you to your research questions? What is the origin story?
- What question keeps you up at night?
- What would be lost if your research did not exist?
- With whom is your work in conversation, and whom is it for?
- If a skeptical colleague asked why it matters, what would you say?
What the statement is, and what it is not
A strong statement names things. It reads as the work of a person who cares about something, and it explains why the work matters beyond the field. Four kinds of writing fall short: a summary of your CV or application materials, a list of topics, a statement written for a search committee, and a description of what you plan to study.
Falls short: “My research interests include digital rhetoric, social media, and public discourse. I have presented at several conferences and plan to study online communities.”
These examples are illustrations written for this guide, drawn from three kinds of CRDM projects. Each label names the field, the goal after the degree, and where the questions came from.
Platform and media studies · faculty career · a family event
Closer: “I started asking how platforms decide whose grief counts after watching my town’s flood become a trending topic for a weekend and then vanish. I study how moderation systems sort public mourning, because the people sorted out of view are the ones the recovery money also misses.”
Technical and professional communication · industry research · prior work
Closer: “I spent six years writing patient-portal messages for a hospital system, and I watched patients answer the questions the interface asked instead of the ones they came with. I study how health interfaces shape what patients believe they are allowed to ask, because the gap between those two sets of questions is where care fails. I want my research to change how portals get designed, so I am aiming at research roles where those design decisions get made.”
Community-engaged and archival rhetoric · public humanities · a reading
Closer: “Saidiya Hartman’s ‘Venus in Two Acts’ turned my interest in nineteenth-century newspapers into a question about absence. I study how a Black mutual aid society in eastern North Carolina recorded itself when the local papers did not, and I am building a digital archive with the society’s descendants. The town’s official history still leaves them out. I want the archive to belong to them before it belongs to my CV.”
Check your draft
Read the statement aloud before you submit it, then ask the questions below.
| Criterion | Complete and substantive | Nearly there |
|---|---|---|
| Voice and conviction | Specific and personal. No stranger would have written it. | Competent but generic. It describes many students in your field, or it reads as written for a committee. |
| Stakes | States why the research matters, within the field and beyond it. | Asserts importance, or falls back on filling a gap in the literature. |
| Origin | Traces where the questions came from, intellectually, experientially, or both. | Describes interests without saying why they emerged or why they still hold you. |
| Synthesis | Argues for an identity as a thinker. | Reads as a chronology of training, publications, or credentials. |
| Audience | Names, outright or by implication, your interlocutors and your readers. | The work sits in a vacuum, with no community or intended effect. |
How it is assessed
- Complete and substantive
- States intellectual purpose and why the research matters, with conviction and specificity. Earns the full 20 points.
- Nearly there
- Engages the prompt but reads as written for a committee, leaves the stakes unclear, or reads as a topic list. Earns 16 points, and a revision to the complete threshold earns the full 20.
- Not yet complete
- Not submitted, or below the expectations for doctoral reflection. Come talk to me.
Submitting
Upload a PDF, Word file, or plain text to Canvas, email it to kkcole2@ncsu.edu, or bring a print copy to class. Every format counts the same. If a format creates a barrier, email me.
Generative AI
Generative AI is permitted for brainstorming or light editing. The substance of the statement must be yours, in your voice, from your own experience and convictions. The reason is practical. The statement exists to surface what you think and want, and no model has access to either. If you are unsure whether a use fits, ask me before you submit.
Getting help
Email kkcole2@ncsu.edu, or find me in my office before class. If the statement is hard to write, the difficulty is worth a conversation.