Movement II · Week 6 · Thursday, February 18
The Labor of Knowledge and the Labor of Committees
In short Before we meet (the reading, what to write and bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan and the committee email workshop), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).
The practical work of candidacy begins this week. We read Federici on whose labor builds a field, then turn her question on ourselves with a recently advanced student and a workshop for your first committee email. Bring a draft, rough or not.
Kirsti
- Read
- Federici, Caliban and the Witch, Introduction and two sections of Chapter 2, and Delgado Bernal and Villalpando, “An Apartheid of Knowledge in Academia”
- Bring
- A committee map and a draft email to your first committee contact
- Guest
- A recently advanced CRDM student, 11:45 to 12:30
- Due
- No milestone this week
Federici asks whose labor built the fields you inherit. The second half of the session turns her question toward your own degree: whose labor will it require, and on what terms do you ask for it?
Before we meet
Read
- Silvia Federici, Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body, and Primitive Accumulation (Autonomedia, 2004). Introduction, pages 11 to 19, and the sections of Chapter 2 from “The Devaluation of Women’s Labor” through “The Patriarchy of the Wage,” pages 92 to 100. (opens in a new tab)
- Dolores Delgado Bernal and Octavio Villalpando, “An Apartheid of Knowledge in Academia: The Struggle Over the ‘Legitimate’ Knowledge of Faculty of Color,” (opens in a new tab) Equity & Excellence in Education 35, no. 2 (2002): 169–180.
- Federici asks whose labor built a field. Delgado Bernal and Villalpando ask whose knowledge the academy counts as legitimate. Read them together before you write to a prospective committee member.
Read with a pen. The marginalia guide describes the practice.
Write and bring
- Your marked copy, with a note beside one passage in Federici bearing on your own field, connecting her argument to a dynamic you recognize.
- A committee map. CRDM committees have four members: a chair from the CRDM core faculty and three more, with at least one from Communication and one from English. Name each person, write two or three sentences on why each belongs, and note whom you have already spoken with. If your Plan of Work already lists a committee, bring it and mark what has changed.
- A draft of the email you will send your first committee contact. We workshop it in class.
Questions to carry into the reading
ShowHide Questions to carry into the reading
- Federici reads the witch hunts as a political campaign to discipline women’s bodies at the dawn of capitalism. What does her argument require you to revise about early modernity?
- Primitive accumulation usually refers to land and labor. Federici extends the concept to bodies and knowledge. Where does the extension appear in the fields you inherit?
- Whose labor built your field? Whose names appear in its canon, and whose do not?
- Delgado Bernal and Villalpando describe an apartheid of knowledge. Whose knowledge will your committee recognize as legitimate, and whose will you need to argue for?
- What has your field enclosed or suppressed? Which knowledges has it made to look like non-knowledge?
- How does Federici’s materialism sit with the discursive frameworks of Mbembe and Brown?
- Committee service is labor, much of it uncounted. What do you owe the faculty you ask to serve, and what do you expect from them in return?
When we meet
Session plan
ShowHide Session plan
| Time | Activity |
|---|---|
| 10:15–10:30 | Opening question: what does primitive accumulation mean in Marx, and what does Federici do to the concept? |
| 10:30–11:15 | Discussion of Federici: the witch hunts as politics, the body as a site of accumulation, the labor behind a field. |
| 11:15–11:30 | From Federici to the committee: whose labor will your degree require? |
| 11:30–11:45 | Break |
| 11:45–12:30 | Conversation with a recently advanced student on choosing a chair and readers, and on writing the first email. |
| 12:30–1:00 | Committee email workshop. |
Committee email workshop
ShowHide Committee email workshop
The workshop turns your committee map into a first message. A strong first ask runs about three sentences: what the project is, why this person, and what you are asking for.
- Trade draft emails with a partner.
- Respond to your partner’s email in writing for ten minutes. Is the ask clear? Does the email convey the project’s stakes? Is it warm without being overfamiliar?
- Discuss your responses, five minutes per email.
- As a group, name the common problems: an ask too vague to answer, too much detail for a first contact, a request for commitment before interest.
- Revise. Then name the person you will write to first and the day you will send the email.
Written route. If you would rather keep the exchange in writing, use the five minutes of discussion to extend your written response, and hand both pages to your partner.
After we meet
- Send at least one committee email within 48 hours of class.
- Keep any replies. They inform your exam list in Weeks 8 and 9.
- If you are unsure whom to ask, or how, email me before Week 8.
Further reading, if this week opened something up
ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
- Saidiya Hartman, “Venus in Two Acts,” on the archive, its silences, and humanistic imagination. It pairs with next week.
- María Lugones, “Heterosexualism and the Colonial/Modern Gender System,” a decolonial feminist extension of Federici.
- Karen Kelsky, The Professor Is In, the chapters on choosing advisors and committee dynamics. Through NC State Libraries.