Movement I · Week 4 · Thursday, February 4

Who Gets to Live

In short Before we meet (the reading, what to write and bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan and the concept translation workshop), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).

Mbembe is short and demanding, so give him two sittings. Ruha Benjamin then carries his questions into the technologies many of you study. The examples you bring will carry much of the conversation, so choose one you care about.

Kirsti

Read
Mbembe, Necropolitics, Chapter 3, and Ruha Benjamin, Race After Technology, Introduction (about 70 pages). Mbembe’s introduction is optional.
Bring
Your marked copy and one example of necropolitical logic
Due
No milestone this week

Mbembe extends Foucault’s biopolitics to ask who is allowed to live and who is made to die, by design. This week tests his concepts against examples you bring.

Before we meet

Read

Read with a pen. The marginalia guide describes the practice.

Write and bring

Questions to carry into the reading

ShowHide Questions to carry into the reading
  • Mbembe distinguishes making live, letting die, and making die. How does the distinction change how you think about power?
  • For Mbembe, necropolitics describes actual bodies in actual places. Where do you see its logic in what you study?
  • What would change in your project if you foregrounded the bodies it touches?
  • Mbembe writes from a specific history and geography. How does his position shape the argument, and how does yours shape your reading?
  • Ruha Benjamin names a New Jim Code: technologies which encode inequity while appearing neutral. Where does her account meet Mbembe’s, and where does it part from it?
  • How do Mbembe and Ruha Benjamin sit alongside, or complicate, Giroux and Walter Benjamin?

When we meet

Session plan

ShowHide Session plan
TimeActivity
10:15–10:30Where does Mbembe say Foucault stops short? (pages 66 to 68)
10:30–11:10Core concepts: sovereignty, the state of exception, the death-world, necropower.
11:10–11:35Your examples, two minutes each, without interruption.
11:35–11:50Break
11:50–12:35Concept translation workshop.
12:35–1:00Synthesis: what critical vocabulary are we building?

Concept translation workshop

ShowHide Concept translation workshop

A test of where a theoretical concept holds and where it strains.

  1. In pairs, map Mbembe’s distinction (making live, letting die, making die) onto your partner’s example.
  2. Push each other: is this necropolitical, or does another framework serve the example better?
  3. As a full group, name where the concept held and where it strained, and what the strain shows about the reach of critical theory.
  4. Write one sentence on how Mbembe has shifted, or left unchanged, the way you frame your research problem.

Written route. If you would rather work in writing, map the distinction on your partner’s card and hand it back, and when the full group gathers, pass your note to me to read aloud.

After we meet

Further reading, if this week opened something up

ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
  • Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth (opens in a new tab), with Sartre’s preface, foundational for postcolonial and critical race frameworks. The 1963 Grove translation is in the Readings folder.
  • Christina Sharpe, In the Wake, which extends Mbembe into Black Studies.