Movement I · Week 3 · Thursday, January 28
The Past Is Not Past
In short Before we meet (the reading, what to write and bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan, and the wreckage and promise gallery), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).
Benjamin is hard, and he repays the effort. Read the “Theses” slowly, bring an object from your research, and come ready to meet a current doctoral student who stood where you stand now.
Kirsti
- Read
- Benjamin, Illuminations, three essays (about 74 pages)
- Bring
- One object from your research area, and one genuine question about the “Theses”
- Guest
- A current CRDM doctoral student, 12:20 to 1:00
- Due
- No milestone this week
Benjamin insists the past is never settled. This week reads three of his essays against the objects you bring from your own research, and a current doctoral student joins us to talk about this stage of the program.
Before we meet
Read
- Walter Benjamin, Illuminations (opens in a new tab), ed. Hannah Arendt, trans. Harry Zohn (Schocken, 2007). Read three essays:
- “The Storyteller,” pages 83 to 109.
- “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction,” pages 217 to 251.
- “Theses on the Philosophy of History,” pages 253 to 264. Short and dense. Give the “Theses” more time than their length suggests.
Read with a pen. The marginalia guide describes the practice.
Write and bring
- One object (a photograph, a text, an image, a sound clip) representing something unresolved in your research area. You need not explain it fully. Be ready to say why it matters.
- Your marked copy, with one moment in the “Theses” you find cryptic flagged and a genuine question written beside it.
Questions to carry into the reading
ShowHide Questions to carry into the reading
- Benjamin writes of history flashing up in a moment of danger. What does his claim do to your research questions?
- What is the angel of history, and what storm drives it? How does the image land for you now?
- Benjamin argues mechanical reproduction destroys aura. What has digital reproduction done to the texts and images you study?
- Who is the storyteller, in Benjamin’s sense, in your own field?
- What piece of history in your research area is not past?
When we meet
A current doctoral student joins us from 12:20 to 1:00 to talk about this stage of the program and what it asks of students.
Session plan
ShowHide Session plan
| Time | Activity |
|---|---|
| 10:15–10:35 | Thesis IX, read aloud. We sit with it before anyone explains it. |
| 10:35–11:10 | “The Storyteller” and “The Work of Art.” What has digital reproduction done to aura? |
| 11:10–11:35 | Working through the “Theses” together. |
| 11:35–11:50 | Break, and setting out objects for the gallery. |
| 11:50–12:20 | Wreckage and promise gallery. |
| 12:20–1:00 | Conversation with a current CRDM doctoral student on this stage of the program, closing on the synthesis question: what are we all working in the wreckage of? |
Wreckage and promise gallery
ShowHide Wreckage and promise gallery
Benjamin’s angel faces the wreckage of the past while a storm drives it forward. The gallery reads your objects the same way.
- Place your object, or a description of it, on the table. Five minutes of silent looking.
- In small groups, ask of each object: what wreckage does it hold, and what promise? How does Thesis IX apply?
- As a full group, name the patterns across the cohort’s objects.
- Write one sentence: “The piece of history I am working in the wreckage of is ___.” Keep it for your Scholarly Identity Statement.
Written route. If you would rather not speak in your group or to the full room, write your answer on a card and hand it to someone in your group or to me, and it enters the conversation the same way a spoken answer does.
After we meet
- Read Mbembe for Week 4, and find an example of necropolitical logic to bring.
- Keep your wreckage sentence for the Identity Statement due in Week 5.
Further reading, if this week opened something up
ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
- Hannah Arendt, “Walter Benjamin: 1892–1940,” (opens in a new tab) her introduction to Illuminations, pages 1 to 55. Essential context.
- Susan Buck-Morss, The Dialectics of Seeing (opens in a new tab), the most thorough account of Benjamin’s method. In the Readings folder.