Movement I · Week 2 · Thursday, January 21
Critical Pedagogy and the Scholar-Critic
In short Before we meet (the reading, what to write and bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan and the institutional autopsy), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).
We begin the reading with Giroux because he asks the question this seminar keeps circling: what does it mean to think critically from inside an institution? Annotate honestly, including where you disagree.
Kirsti
- Read
- Giroux, two essays from 1979 and 2004 (about 39 pages)
- Bring
- Your marked copy and one example from your own education
- Due
- No milestone this week
Giroux argues education is never neutral. This week asks what it means to be a critic inside an institution which grades, funds, and credentials you.
Before we meet
Read
- Henry A. Giroux, “Schooling and the Culture of Positivism: Notes on the Death of History,” (opens in a new tab) Educational Theory 29, no. 4 (1979): 263–84.
- Henry A. Giroux, “Critical Pedagogy and the Postmodern/Modern Divide: Towards a Pedagogy of Democratization,” (opens in a new tab) Teacher Education Quarterly 31, no. 1 (2004): 31–47.
- Both open through NC State Libraries, with no limit on readers. Sign in with your Unity ID and download the PDF. Giroux revised both essays as Chapters 1 and 3 of On Critical Pedagogy, 2nd ed. (Bloomsbury, 2020).
- Read them as two moments in one career, and note what Giroux keeps and what he drops across twenty-five years.
Read with a pen. The marginalia guide describes the practice.
Write and bring
- Your marked copy, with two passages flagged for class: one you agree with and one you push back on, each with two or three sentences in the margin.
- One concrete example from your own education which confirms or complicates Giroux’s argument.
Questions to carry into the reading
ShowHide Questions to carry into the reading
- What does it mean to be a critic inside an institution? How do you critique the hand which grades you?
- Giroux holds education either domesticates or liberates. Do you agree? Where have you experienced either?
- What does it mean to be educated inside a university which treats you as human capital?
- What does critical pedagogy ask of you, as a student and as a future teacher?
- Where do you feel the tension between institutional belonging and intellectual dissent most sharply?
When we meet
Session plan
ShowHide Session plan
| Time | Activity |
|---|---|
| 10:15–10:30 | The reading lead opens with the reading note and its question. |
| 10:30–11:25 | Seminar discussion of Giroux. |
| 11:25–11:40 | Break |
| 11:40–12:25 | Institutional autopsy. |
| 12:25–12:50 | Synthesis: which assumptions named today connect to the questions you raised in Week 1? |
| 12:50–1:00 | Preparing for Week 3, including the object you will bring. |
Institutional autopsy
ShowHide Institutional autopsy
An inventory of the rules of academic life we follow without examining them.
- In pairs, each of you names one rule, norm, or unspoken expectation of academic life you have accepted without question.
- Share them with the room. I list them on the board without comment.
- As a group, decide which Giroux would call hegemonic, which are useful, and which deserve breaking.
- Write one sentence: “The assumption I am most committed to interrogating this semester is ___.”
Written route. If you would rather write than talk, write your rule on a card, show it to your partner, and pass it to me when we share with the room. I list it on the board with the others, without naming who wrote it.
After we meet
- Read Benjamin for Week 3, and choose the object you will bring.
Further reading, if this week opened something up
ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
- bell hooks, Teaching to Transgress, more direct than Giroux on the embodied experience of the critical classroom.
- Stuart Hall, “Cultural Studies and Its Theoretical Legacies,” on intellectual formation and the cost of thinking critically inside institutions.