Movement II · Week 9 · Thursday, March 11
Situated Knowledges: Revising the List
In short Before we meet (the reading, what to write and bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan and the canon audit of the draft list), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).
Haraway helps us ask where we stand when we claim to know something. A faculty member who chairs committees joins us, and we audit our lists together. Bring whatever your committee contacts have said.
Kirsti
- Read
- Haraway, “Situated Knowledges,” and Chakravartty et al., “#CommunicationSoWhite” (about 38 pages)
- Bring
- Your revised draft list, a standpoint paragraph, and any committee responses
- Guest
- A program faculty member who chairs committees, 10:50 to 11:40
- Due
- No milestone this week
Haraway argues against the view from nowhere. This week applies her argument to your list, alongside a faculty member who reads lists from the committee’s side of the table.
Before we meet
Read
- Donna Haraway, “Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective,” Feminist Studies 14, no. 3 (1988): 575–599. Read it on JSTOR through NC State Libraries (opens in a new tab).
- Paula Chakravartty, Rachel Kuo, Victoria Grubbs, and Charlton McIlwain, “#CommunicationSoWhite,” (opens in a new tab) Journal of Communication 68, no. 2 (2018): 254–266. Free to read.
- Read Haraway for the argument and Chakravartty and colleagues for the evidence: a citation study of whose work communication journals publish and cite. The canon audit uses both.
Read with a pen. The marginalia guide describes the practice.
Write and bring
- Your draft list, revised after peer review.
- One paragraph on where you stand when you claim to know your problem, drawing on Haraway.
- Any responses from prospective committee members, with a note on what each changed.
Questions to carry into the reading
ShowHide Questions to carry into the reading
- Haraway argues against the view from nowhere. From where does your list claim to know, and does its structure show it?
- Chakravartty and colleagues show whose work the field cites. Run their question on your own list: whose work does it cite, and whose does it leave out?
- Which fields will read your dissertation first? Which will read it skeptically?
- If your project is interdisciplinary, which field claims it first, and what does the claim cost the others?
- If your project sits within one discipline, which position in the field does your list take, and which does it leave out?
- What did your committee contacts say about the list, and what did their responses show about where they stand?
When we meet
Session plan
ShowHide Session plan
| Time | Activity |
|---|---|
| 10:15–10:50 | Haraway: what does it mean to claim knowledge from a located position? |
| 10:50–11:40 | Conversation with a program faculty member on how faculty read a draft list and what they weigh when asked to serve. |
| 11:40–11:55 | Break |
| 11:55–12:35 | Canon audit of the draft lists. |
| 12:35–12:55 | Revision: one addition and one cut, each grounded in Haraway or in a committee response. |
| 12:55–1:00 | Close: what will you bring to your individual meeting? |
Canon audit of the draft list
ShowHide Canon audit of the draft list
The audit works on your own draft. Auditing a canon in the abstract describes a field. Auditing your own list asks you to decide what to change.
- Work from your Week 8 draft, revised after peer review.
- For each text, note the author’s apparent position, as far as you know it. Mark texts centering Global South, feminist, queer, or disabled perspectives.
- As a group, describe the demographic and disciplinary shape of the lists this cohort has drafted. Then run the same audit on two past CRDM exam lists (opens in a new tab): what has the program canon looked like?
- Name one text absent from your list which belongs there, and one text you will cut. Both changes go into the list you bring to your individual meeting.
Written route. If you would rather not speak when the group describes the lists, write your observation on a card and hand it to me, and I will add it to the board.
After we meet
- Book your individual meeting for the March 11 to 24 window. Office hours are limited those weeks, so find an open time on my calendar (opens in a new tab) and send me an invitation.
- Revise your list for Milestone 3, due March 24, with the addition and cut from today.
Further reading, if this week opened something up
ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
- Patricia Hill Collins, Black Feminist Thought, on standpoint epistemology and the matrix of domination.
- Kimberlé Crenshaw, “Mapping the Margins,” the foundational text on intersectionality.