Movement II · Week 8 · Thursday, March 4

Exam List Workshop

In short Before we meet (the milestone due, what to bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan and the structured peer review), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).

Your committee confirmation is due, and your working list is the reading for the day. Peer review works best on a real draft, so bring what you have, gaps and all. The list itself is due March 24.

Kirsti

Read
Your partner’s draft list and rationale, in class
Bring
Your Draft Exam List and rationale, in print or on a laptop
Due
Milestone 2, Committee Confirmation, before class

Your draft list is the reading this week. A good list makes an argument about a field and your place in it, and a reader from outside your project should be able to see the argument.

Before we meet

Milestone due: Committee Confirmation

Either an email from your chair confirming their willingness to serve, or a written plan naming faculty for each position, the status of each conversation, and a realistic timeline. Faculty replies in February run slow, so a credible plan meets the threshold. If you have hit obstacles, such as a faculty member who has not replied or uncertainty about whom to ask, say so in the submission. 15% of the final grade. Submit through Canvas or by email.

Full guide to the Committee Confirmation milestone

Bring

Questions for peer review

ShowHide Questions for peer review
  • What intellectual logic holds the list together: theme, method, genealogy, intervention?
  • Where are the temporal, geographic, or demographic gaps? Which fields or traditions are absent?
  • Does the list reflect what the field values, what you value, or what your committee values, and do the three agree?
  • Which fields will read this dissertation, and from what position does the list enter each?
  • Is there a text on the list you have not read? What would a list you wanted to read look like?

When we meet

Session plan

ShowHide Session plan
TimeActivity
10:15–10:25Framing: a good list makes an argument about a field.
10:25–11:50Structured peer review in pairs.
11:50–12:05Break
12:05–12:40Full group: where do our lists overlap, and where do they diverge?
12:40–1:00Each of you names one revision to make before Week 9 and shares it with your reviewer.

Structured peer review

ShowHide Structured peer review

Pairs are assigned. Each reader responds in writing before any discussion begins.

  1. Exchange lists and rationale paragraphs.
  2. Respond in writing for fifteen minutes: the organizing logic I see, a gap I notice, a text I would add and why, the most interesting tension on the list, and one question for the author about the choices behind it.
  3. Discuss the responses, ten minutes per list.
  4. Join the full group to compare what the lists reveal about the cohort, and set them beside the past CRDM exam lists (opens in a new tab).

Written route. If you would rather keep the review in writing, use the ten minutes of discussion to extend your written response, and when the full group gathers, hand your notes to me to read into the comparison.

After we meet

Further reading, if this week opened something up

ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
  • Sandra Harding, “Is There a Feminist Method?”, the classic overview of feminist epistemology and a companion to next week’s reading.