Movement III · Week 13 · Thursday, April 8
Paths Forward: Alt-Ac and Otherwise
In short Before we meet (what to write and bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan and the How Knowledge Travels activity), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).
Our guests this week work beyond the academy. Come curious, and bring three versions of your project, written for three different readers.
Kirsti
- Read
- No required reading
- Bring
- Three 100-word versions of your project, and one piece of scholarly writing you admire
- Guests
- CRDM graduates working outside the academy, 10:30 to 11:25
- Due
- No milestone this week
Graduates working beyond the academy join us to talk about what the PhD prepares you for. This week asks how to describe your expertise to different readers, and how to design a prospectus which serves more than one future.
Before we meet
Write and bring
- Three versions of the same project description, 100 words each: for a hiring committee in your field, for a foundation or nonprofit grant panel, and for a journalist writing about your research area.
- One piece of scholarly communication from your field you admire: an article, a chapter, or a public essay. Know its genre, its venue, and what its opening paragraph does.
- A one-page venue and funding map. Name three journals where your work would land, two conferences where it would be welcome, one public or industry venue, and two sources of support for your dissertation year, such as a Graduate School or college fellowship, an external dissertation fellowship, or a professional organization grant in your field. Give each a sentence on why it fits, and note one deadline. The handout lists places to start.
Questions to carry into the session
ShowHide Questions to carry into the session
- What has the PhD given you beyond your content area: which skills, frameworks, and habits of thought?
- How do you describe your expertise to someone in a hiring context outside your field?
- What would a public version of your project look like: a policy brief, an essay, a community partnership?
- What do you fear losing if you leave, or never enter, the tenure track? What might you gain?
- How do you design a dissertation which opens doors?
When we meet
I went from my undergraduate degree into a PhD and then into a tenure-track position, a path few now follow. Our guests know this terrain better than I do. We ask them to speak with candor.
Session plan
ShowHide Session plan
| Time | Activity |
|---|---|
| 10:15–10:30 | Your three versions, shared in small groups. What stays constant across them? |
| 10:30–11:25 | Conversation with our guests. |
| 11:25–11:40 | Break |
| 11:40–12:25 | How knowledge travels: venue and funding maps, then two abstracts. |
| 12:25–1:00 | Three versions side by side, then a go-around: one thing you now want your prospectus to do. |
How knowledge travels
ShowHide How knowledge travels
Which venues matter, what each genre does, and what an abstract is for are usually learned through mentorship and chance. This activity makes the knowledge explicit.
- Venue and funding maps, as a full group: each of you shares one journal, one conference, and one funding source from your map. We build a shared list the cohort keeps.
- Discuss who built the prestige hierarchy in your subfield, and which venues welcome interdisciplinary CRDM work.
- Draft two abstracts: a 250-word conference abstract (problem, scholarship, method, argument, stakes) and a 100-word public pitch opening with the human problem.
- Trade both with a partner. What changes between the versions? Which gives the more honest account of why the work matters?
- Close: name the first venue you are aiming for, and ask whether your prospectus is framed for it.
Written route. If you would rather not speak to the full group, write your journal, conference, and funding source on a card and hand it to me for the shared list. Your partner reads your two abstracts on the page, so the trade needs no talk at all.
After we meet
- Finish your full prospectus draft, due before Week 14, with a one-paragraph director’s note.
- If you chose the nonacademic prospectus option, confirm its form with me this week.
Further reading, if this week opened something up
ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
- Karen Kelsky, The Professor Is In, the chapters on careers beyond the academy.
- Kathleen Fitzpatrick, Generous Thinking, on public scholarship and work with communities beyond the academy.