Movement III · Week 11 · Thursday, March 25
Method and the Dissertation Imagination
In short Before we meet (the reading, what to write and bring, and questions to carry), then when we meet (the session plan and the methodology card exercise), then after we meet (next steps and further reading).
Welcome back from break. Movement III opens with the question your committee will ask first: why this method? Smagorinsky argues the method section is where a project earns or loses a reader’s trust, so we read him beside a model prospectus and your own first paragraph.
Kirsti
- Read
- Smagorinsky, “The Method Section as Conceptual Epicenter” (about 23 pages), and one model prospectus sketch
- Bring
- A prospectus paragraph and a method paragraph, plus your research question and three candidate methods
- Due
- No milestone this week
Smagorinsky argues the method section sits at the conceptual center of a research report, because it shows how evidence becomes a claim. This week applies his argument to your prospectus and asks you to argue for your method on epistemological grounds.
Before we meet
Read
- Peter Smagorinsky, “The Method Section as Conceptual Epicenter in Constructing Social Science Research Reports,” (opens in a new tab) Written Communication 25, no. 3 (2008): 389–411.
- Smagorinsky writes about qualitative social science. Rhetorical, historical, and textual projects make the same argument in another register, so read for what any reader needs before trusting how you move from evidence to claim.
Read with a pen. The marginalia guide describes the practice.
Write and bring
- Your marked copy of one of the three model prospectus sketches. Mark where each of the five elements begins, and write the first question a committee member would ask.
- Your first prospectus paragraph: the problem, why it matters, and who it is for.
- A second paragraph naming what a skeptical reader would need to know about your method before trusting your claims.
- Your working research question, stated as a question, with three methods which might answer it and one sentence on what each would let you see.
Questions to carry into the reading
ShowHide Questions to carry into the reading
- Smagorinsky argues readers decide whether to trust a study in its method section. What would a reader need from yours?
- What counts as evidence in your project, and what happens to it between collection and claim?
- Smagorinsky writes from qualitative social science. What does his argument ask of rhetorical, historical, or textual projects?
- Which part of your method would be hardest to explain to a committee member from another field?
When we meet
The methods activity rests on three distinctions. A method is what you do: close reading, interviews, archival research, corpus analysis. A methodology is the framework which justifies the method, given what it assumes about knowing: rhetorical criticism, critical ethnography, feminist standpoint theory. An epistemology is the underlying claim about what counts as knowledge. “I will use discourse analysis” names a method. “Because language constitutes social reality, discourse analysis suits this question better than content analysis” makes a methodological argument.
Session plan
ShowHide Session plan
| Time | Activity |
|---|---|
| 10:15–10:30 | Back from break: what did you read for pleasure? |
| 10:30–11:00 | Smagorinsky: the method section as the place where evidence becomes a claim. |
| 11:00–11:35 | Prospectus paragraphs and model sketches read aloud: where does each name its method, and what does it leave unexplained? |
| 11:35–11:50 | Break |
| 11:50–12:35 | Method, methodology, epistemology. |
| 12:35–1:00 | Synthesis: what will your method section need to show? |
Method, methodology, epistemology
ShowHide Method, methodology, epistemology
Your committee will ask why your question requires your method. This activity has you make the argument first, against a partner who looks for its gaps.
- Five minutes: fill out a methodology card with your question, method, methodology, the argument linking them, one ruled-out alternative, and your greatest uncertainty.
- Ten minutes: trade cards. Your partner asks whether another method would answer the question as well, whether your epistemological claim does any work, and what the strongest counterargument is.
- Ten minutes: each of you names one mismatch, gap, or assumption the pressure test exposed.
- Fifteen minutes: draft a paragraph of three to five sentences stating your question, naming your method and its methodology, and arguing for your approach against a named alternative.
- Five minutes: two or three volunteers read their paragraphs. Is the epistemological argument visible?
Written route. If you would rather answer your partner in writing, write your replies on the methodology card and hand it back. Reading a paragraph aloud at the close is voluntary.
After we meet
- Revise your methodology paragraph and add it to your prospectus draft before Week 14.
- If your methodological framework still feels unsettled, talk with your committee chair before writing the full methodology section.
- Write the 150-word audience test for Week 12.
Further reading, if this week opened something up
ShowHide Further reading, if this week opened something up
- Herbert Marcuse, One-Dimensional Man (opens in a new tab), 2nd ed. (Routledge Classics, 2002), Introduction and Chapters 1 and 3, on how a society absorbs dissent. In the Readings folder.
- Robin D. G. Kelley, Freedom Dreams, on imagination as scholarly and political practice.
- Safiya Umoja Noble, Algorithms of Oppression, a model of a critical methodological argument made explicit.
- danah boyd and Kate Crawford, “Critical Questions for Big Data,” on the assumptions inside computational methods.